I’m going to use a homegrown system for scoring things when I actually come to reviewing a product. Note that not every blog post is going to be a review – many may simply be comments on what I’m considering or actually playing with. On the other hand, a review might not be several pages of in depth text – it may simply be a few words and how I feel scores should be allocated.
I’ve decided on four categories for now. If they don’t prove sufficient, I may reconsider at a later point. Clearly, the first category is where many reviewers would focus, but I believe that they all deserve a reasonable voice in the sorts of reviews I’m hoping to do.
Each will be given an integer score between 0 and 9. I’m intentionally keeping the score to single digits for the scores. I don’t feel a range of 5 is sufficient to distinguish between things, and I think a percentage would end up too arbitrary. At the end an overall score will be decided based on the average of the scores leading up to it, rounding down any decimal values to integers. Yes, this means an average score of 8.9 will be rounded to 8.
Here are my categories:
Effectiveness
Put simply, does it do the job I set out to do. Can I go from a standing start all the way to the finish point and be happy with the result. A high score will achieve my intended result at least as much as I had hoped, if not more. Lower scores might be given to things that are marketted as doing the job and fail, or that simply go some of the distance and achieve a result that even if acceptable, are not quite what I would like (software can always be improved, can’t it?).
Convenience
How easy is it to go from wanting to engage in a task to actually engaging in the task. If something takes a lot of set up and preparation before actually progressing and/or is riddled with unrelated interruptions throughout, then it will score low. Maximum points go to things that require no set up, with things that require an understandable amount of preparation (such as a journey to the town centre) still scoring high.
Efficiency
Once I get started on something, how smooth is the journey to the end point. In order to achieve my end result, how much is there that needs to be done on top of what I feel is appropriate to reach my end goal. Some tools in this world offer so many features these days, that even the best new technology might create hurdles that get in your way, that something from a decade ago might have achieved much more efficiently.
Cost
Many things in this world cost money, though the highest scoring things in this category would be representative of their being free. One off prices are fine if the product is worth the money, as indeed are recurring costs (subscriptions) if the product is worth it, or it feels right to support whichever company or individual created it. Something’s worth is primarily judged by how much something gets used in daily life for more expensive items, though quality factors in too of course – especially for things that aren’t going to be used often by definition.
I’m going to use a homegrown system for scoring things when I actually come to reviewing a product. Note that not every blog post is going to be a review – many may simply be comments on what I’m considering or actually playing with. On the other hand, a review might not be several pages of in depth text – it may simply be a few words and how I feel scores should be allocated.
I’ve decided on four categories for now. If they don’t prove sufficient, I may reconsider at a later point. Clearly, the first category is where many reviewers would focus, but I believe that they all deserve a reasonable voice in the sorts of reviews I’m hoping to do.
Each will be given an integer score between 0 and 9. I’m intentionally keeping the score to single digits for the scores. I don’t feel a range of 5 is sufficient to distinguish between things, and I think a percentage would end up too arbitrary. At the end an overall score will be decided based on the average of the scores leading up to it, rounding down any decimal values to integers. Yes, this means an average score of 8.9 will be rounded to 8.
Here are my categories:
Read more…
Tags: